Tags
American history, Dumas Malone, Jon Meacham, Joseph Ellis, Merrill Peterson, presidential biographies, Presidents, Thomas Jefferson
Having finished reading the seven books I own on John Adams it’s finally time to move to our third president: Thomas Jefferson.
In some ways even more enigmatic and complex than John Adams (if that’s possible), Jefferson is widely viewed as one of our best presidents, but also one of the most difficult to truly get to know.
On average, he ranks fourth in terms of popularity as a “great” president in the dozen or so surveys I have collected, just behind Lincoln, FDR and Washington…and well ahead of poor John Adams (who ranks twelfth on average by my math).
Not only has Jefferson attracted a large number of fans (and biographers), but he has also generated a great deal of controversy – concerning his presumed relationship(s) with his slaves, his duplicitous nature (revealed partially in his extensive correspondence with Adams) and his views toward organized religion (apparently Calvinism and the Catholic Church in particular).
But until I’ve marched somewhat through my 18″ high stack of biographies on Jefferson, he remains largely an unpainted canvass for me – other than the fact I know him to be the principal author of the Declaration of Independence, a diplomat, a Secretary of State, a Vice President, a two-term President, a slave owner, the mastermind behind Monticello and founder of the highly regarded University of Virginia (which, as a Virginia resident, I am hopeful my kids will one day attend).
First up is preeminent Jefferson biographer Dumas Malone’s six-volume Pulitzer-prize winning “Jefferson and His Time”. Written between 1948 and 1981, Malone’s biography of Jefferson promises to be for Jefferson what Flexner was for Washington and Page Smith was for John Adams. Many biographies have been written since Malone’s monumental effort, but as far as I can tell, none have surpassed his work.
Next will be Merrill Peterson’s weighty biography “Thomas Jefferson and the New Nation”. This seems to be generally considered the “best” single-volume biography of Jefferson. Published in 1970, Peterson apparently considered this his finest work.
Finishing off my tour through Jefferson will be “American Sphinx” by Joseph Ellis, “Twilight at Monticello” by Alan Pell Crawford and Jon Meacham’s recent “Thomas Jefferson: The Art of Power”. There are several others I would like to read (given the controversy they generated, if nothing else) but time is short and I’ve still got another 65,000 pages or so to get through before my eyesight fails.
In addition to learning more about Jefferson, I’m particularly interested to see whether any of the more recent Jefferson biographies on my list can stand up to Malone’s original masterpiece. We’ll see…
I can’t wait to read about your journey through Jefferson. Good luck! I’m waiting for American Sphinx to arrive fromt he library as we speak.
The stack of books I have to get through before I get to American Sphinx looks intimidating, but I’m looking forward to it. Books by Ellis have been consistently ok, but not great, for me so far. Time will tell whether that remains true for this one…
I’m eager to see what you think of Meacham’s Art of Power. I’ve been interested in reading that one for a while. Make sure you take a visit to Monticello once you have your new found Jefferson knowledge : ).
The stories about him founding the University of Virginia are pretty ridiculous, I think you’ll get a kick out of it. Although I guess they could be presented in a more depressing manner than the way I heard them.
I can’t wait either. I thought about going in reverse order, starting with the newest biographies in order to read Meacham’s first. I’ve heard significant chatter about it, mostly negative, but I’m eager to read it nonetheless (or perhaps because of that). Monticello is just 90 minutes down the road from me, so it’s definitely on my “to do” list. I have flown over it and gotten some pretty good pictures, so those will be posted shortly (maybe when I’m in the middle of the 1,000 pg Peterson bio).
Although old and ignored I enjoyed Albert Jay’s Nock’s work on Jefferson. I hesitate to call it a biography as Nock had unusual views on what should be included in a biography. It should really have been called ‘The Mind of Thomas Jefferson’ as we learn more about his surveying abilities than his work during the Revolution.
That’s definitely one I don’t have in my library but I’m adding it to my follow-up list to scope out when I circle back to read everything I realize I failed to catch the first time through. I don’t mind old (obviously), and I don’t mind reading things ignored – I’m always looking for hidden gems
I have reviewed Crawford and Meacham, so I look forward to seeing your take on them. Joe Ellis is….well, Joe Ellis; so good luck with that one.